Next week I’ll be kicking off the eleventh session of the Women’s Leadership Series. The Women’s Leadership Series is an intimate community of female leaders who are looking to grow and activate their authentic selves to become more effective leaders. Participants are invited to take an honest look in the mirror and discover the courage to take new action. As I thought about bringing together a new community of women, I reflected on what it means to be a woman in leadership, and some of the challenges that persist.
Women are constantly asking themselves some version of the question, “Do I take care?” or “Do I take charge?” I hear us asking each other and ourselves questions like, “Do I speak up in the meeting and share my knowledge or do I listen to the perspectives of those that have more experience? Do I hold the person who isn’t performing accountable or do I find out what is going on behind the scenes and give them another shot? Do I take a stand when I am interrupted, or do I let it slide? Bottom line, women often feel damned if they do and doomed if they don’t.
What feels like a dilemma between being a female and being a leader is fueled by gender stereotypes alive in organizations. Women who fight against the two different energy forces at play here – feminine energy (taking care) and masculine energy (taking charge) often struggle to find their way in organizations and advance in their careers.
The challenge is fueled by the cultural bias that invades our daily lives and often affects perception – society’s prescriptive gender stereotype bias. It says that women and men should behave in ways that are gender consistent. So, for women in leadership positions here is what happens. We are first held to the feminine standard of being approachable, taking care, nurturing relationships. And when we don’t our credibility is diminished and our ability to influence is impacted. As leaders we are also working with what researchers call, “think leader think male mindset”. Here women are held to the masculine standard of being confident in what we know, taking charge, and delivering results. Again, when we don’t our credibility is diminished and our ability to influence impacted.
Our male colleagues are perceived through a male male stereotype and while increasingly encouraged to exhibit greater warmth, care, concern their credibility isn’t significantly undermined when they don’t and exponentially enhanced when they do.
What if this expectation of women leaders is a blessing in disguise? What if this cultural bias challenges women to enhance our personal strengths with the full range of what we are capable of? After all, women tend to both take care and take charge inside the organization called, Home.
As Brené Brown so eloquently articulated in her most recent book, Braving the Wildnerness, “we need to bring a soft front and strong back to the world today”. When I think about this paradox and how it pertains to leadership, and more specifically women in leadership, I believe women may have an opportunity and even an advantage.
People want and organizations need what women are capable of and uniquely talented at – tapping into BOTH/AND. Both taking charge and taking care, both being approachable and being authoritative, both executing tasks and nurturing relationships, both delivering profits and creating cultures that instill purpose. Something I call transformational leadership – a style of leadership that integrates both masculine and feminine qualities and allows women (and men) to use it with great success and without penalty.
It takes courage to move beyond the bias and ask the question, I understand what popular conceptions of leadership are, but do we really want to perpetuate these stereotypes? Isn’t it time for both males and females to lead with both soft and strong?
Well said, Kelly! Thanks for sharing; your comments are causing me to reflect…
Kelly, Beautifully written and thought-provoking piece. I so appreciate your outcome-focused view of this paradox as an opportunity. Instead of framing the challenges women leaders face as a problem, you articulate it as an invitation to growth, clarity, and inspiration.